On Congress Funding Levee Repair

On April 13, the federal government said that Louisiana might not have to pay 35 percent of the cost of the levee work that the US Army Corps of Engineers says must be done to certify the levees.

Most people don’t realize that 35% of the money that paid for the shoddy Corps-built levees was local money. Even though the Corps is 100% responsible for the design and construction of the levees, it is the role of the state to come up with 35% of the cost. Since 1965, the state’s levee boards have been raising the state’s share and handing it over to the Corps. This is not disputed.

So the current proposal for Louisiana to pay for 35% of the cost to fix the levees is not reasonable. Louisiana and its citizens had no control over the design and construction of the levee system nor how the money was spent. The federal government had a fiduciary duty to spend our money correctly the first time. For us to pay for the repairs and betterments makes no sense.

Congress has yet to acknowledge that the Corps of Engineers has failed the citizens of Louisiana. This is so despite Lt Gen Carl Strock’s admission of culpability on the levee design, and despite Dan Hitchings, Director of Task Force Hope’s admission that the Corps is accountable to Congress and to the American people.

It is time that Congress acknowledged that an agency of the federal government created the worst engineering disaster in American history. And it is high time that Congress start taking water management in Louisiana seriously.

Sandy Rosenthal

Read More » Leave a comment

Rep Hensarling’s Choice Comments

Texas Representative Jeb Hensarling recently visited New Orleans. While here he blasted state and local officials, saying they want a big federal handout without taking any responsibility or showing accountability. He even has some choice comments for the citizens. “Those able-bodied individuals under 65, what are they doing to help themselves?”

This undeserved criticism was especially harsh since the death and destruction that metro New Orleanians suffered was due to disastrous design and planning mistakes by the US Army Corps of Engineers – a federal agency.

As a member of Congress, Representative Hensarling certainly must know that the Corps of Engineers has sole authority over the design and construction of New Orleans’ flood protection. And everyone knows that Katrina missed New Orleans. Yet the federally built levees failed catastrophically all over the City.

Dan Hitchings, the Director of Task Force Hope with the Corps of Engineers told me in a meeting February 15, 2006 that “the Corps is accountable to the people and to Congress for the performance of the flood protection.” Clearly it didn’t perform.

It is time for the federal government to acknowledge the Corps’ causal role in the flooding. And it is high time that Congress provide the resources necessary to make the citizens of metro New Orleans whole.

Sandy Rosenthal
Founder

Read More » Leave a comment

New Orleans local levee boards are not the problem

In this week’s Time magazine, the article The Big Blank Canvas says levee board consolidation “was an essential signal to Congress that money sent to Louisiana would not drop down a sinkhole.”  That statement is another example of the Myth of the Levee Boards.

Louisiana has no control over federal flood protection money. Louisiana reformed their levee boards because its citizens discovered they needed to more carefully watch and monitor the US Army Corps of Engineers.  The Corps is the sole authority over designing and building New Orleans’ flood protection and only the Corps spends federal money for the levees.  The old levee boards were little more than grass cutters and tax collectors who raised and paid Louisiana’s share of the cost of the levees (30%).  However, the new levee boards will have engineering expertise, university appointed personnel, wider authority and a clear mission of safety.  Most importantly the new levee boards will carefully check and recheck everything the Corps does in the future because we have learned that we cannot blindly trust the Corps to build the levees right.

Sandy Rosenthal
Founder, Levees.Org

Read More » Leave a comment